Reviewed by Aaron Haynes
Most
3dmm short movies fall into one of two categories: a bizarre
scribbling of a general idea (or sometimes the lack of one), or
a dark, depressing drama, often with a twist ending. Hangman
subscribes to the latter almost completely, but this isn't a
detriment. It's well made, interesting, and employs a voiceover
technique I wish more 3DMM directors would try; it uses the
onscreen visuals to enhance the narration, unfolding the plot in
two different storytelling methods simultaneously.
So what, you say. It's a simple monotone narrative overlapping
mediocre animation and basic directing techniques. That may be
the case, but rarely is it this engrossing or pulled off this
well. It's best to go into the movie not knowing what to expect
for this reason -- when certain things about the title become
clear, you're watching a specific something slowly unfold before
your eyes as the narration gives you all the details you need to
know. It's a really cool technique and manages to give the
viewer different aspects of a major plot point in all the right
ways at the same time.
It begins and ends with a poem by Emily Dickenson. A man has
lost his wife and spends his days wishing he could be with her,
no matter what he has to do. A shady character shows up at his
door, claiming he can give him what he wants. As the plot
unfolds, I began to wonder just where the story was going,
especially when the man's wish looks like it's finally being
granted....but is it really? The wordplay on "Elysium" made me
smile, and the ending was suitably creepy and a neat idea, if
not exactly airtight, plotwise. It's not a great movie, but it's
a neat short and I was pleasantly surprised.
The reviews I read on other sites gave Hangman a backseat to the
Unleash the Dragon preview attached to the beginning. I hate to
think of this as just a hype vehicle for an ultra-ambitious
project that ended up being released in an extremely neutered
form, but the
length of the preview and the fact that it's given front billing
make me wonder if that was Frogman's intent. The presentation
makes this cool little short seem almost like an afterthought,
which I think is kind of depressing.
Critical Score: 78/100.
Personal Score: 80/100.
|